A Question of Trustविश्वास का प्रश्न — Victor Canning
📘 Class 10 English · NCERT🏔️ Uttarakhand Board (UBSE)✍️ Chapter
🖍️ yellow = key term · green = character/name · pink = theme/message · orange = exam phrase · date = important date · ★ IMP = most expected question
the safe — £15,000 jewels
Horace loves rare books
flowers → hay fever!
a key on a hook
✏️ About the Author / Poet
Victor Canning (1911–1986) was a British writer of thrillers and children’s books. This story is a light, ironic tale of a thief tricked by another thief.
💡 Theme in one line Never trust strangers blindly; wrong means never justify good ends; ironic proof that there is no honour among thieves.
📖 Summary (English)
one robbery a year
Horace Danby was about fifty, unmarried, and lived with a housekeeper. Everyone thought him a good, honest citizen. He was an expert lock-maker with a few helpers. But he had a secret: he loved rare and expensive books, and to buy them he robbed one safe every year. He had been in prison once, fifteen years ago, and he hated prison.
safe behind a painting
This year he chose Shotover Grange. For two weeks he studied the house — rooms, wiring, paths, garden. The family was in London and the two servants had gone to the cinema. The safe held jewels worth about fifteen thousand pounds; he hoped to get at least five thousand from them. Wearing gloves, he took the key from a hook, entered, and calmed the dog Sherry by calling her by name. The drawing room was full of flowers, and he suffered from hay fever — he felt like sneezing.
lady in red
Just as he began working on the safe behind a painting, a young, pretty lady dressed in red appeared at the door. She said she was the lady of the house and threatened to call the police, but then — charmingly — asked him to open the safe for her because she had forgotten the combination and wanted her jewels for a party. Horace, eager to escape, agreed. He took off his gloves to light her cigarette and then opened the safe with his bare hands. He gave her the jewels and left happily.
arrested — librarian in jail
Two days later the police arrested Horace for the jewel robbery — his fingerprints were all over the safe. The lady in red was a thief herself, not the owner. Nobody believed his story about her. In prison, Horace became assistant librarian, but he still thinks about the charming lady who tricked him.
🗺️ Story / Idea Flow-chart
Horace: lock-maker, book lover➜Robs one safe a year➜Plans Shotover Grange (2 weeks)➜Enters with gloves; dog Sherry➜Lady in red appears➜Takes off gloves, opens safe➜She takes jewels➜Police: fingerprints → arrested➜Prison librarian
📖 सारांश (हिंदी में)
हॉरेस डैनबी लगभग पचास वर्ष का अविवाहित व्यक्ति था, जिसे सब ईमानदार नागरिक मानते थे। वह ताले बनाने में कुशल था। पर उसे दुर्लभ और महँगी किताबों का शौक था, जिनके लिए वह हर साल एक तिजोरी तोड़ता था। वह पंद्रह साल पहले एक बार जेल जा चुका था।
इस बार उसने शॉटओवर ग्रेंज चुना, जिसकी तिजोरी में लगभग पंद्रह हज़ार पाउंड के गहने थे। दो सप्ताह तक उसने घर का अध्ययन किया। दस्ताने पहनकर वह अंदर गया और कुत्ते शेरी को नाम से पुकारकर शांत किया। कमरे में फूल थे और उसे हे-फ़ीवर (फूलों से एलर्जी) थी।
तभी लाल कपड़ों में एक सुंदर महिला आई और खुद को घर की मालकिन बताया। उसने कहा कि वह तिजोरी का कोड भूल गई है और हॉरेस से तिजोरी खुलवाई। हॉरेस ने दस्ताने उतार दिए और नंगे हाथों से तिजोरी खोल दी। दो दिन बाद उँगलियों के निशान के कारण पुलिस ने उसे पकड़ लिया। वह महिला खुद एक चोर थी। जेल में हॉरेस सहायक पुस्तकालयाध्यक्ष बन गया।
📝 Detailed Key Notes
fingerprints!
1. Facts
Horace: about 50, bachelor, lock-maker; loves rare books.
One theft a year; prison 15 years ago.
Target: Shotover Grange; studied for 2 weeks.
Jewels worth £15,000; expected £5,000.
Dog: Sherry; ailment: hay fever.
Lady: young, pretty, dressed in red.
Ending: assistant librarian in prison.
lady in red = thief
2. Where Horace went wrong
He trusted a stranger without checking.
He removed his gloves → fingerprints.
He was charmed and flattered by the lady.
He was in a hurry to leave.
3. Irony
A professional thief is outwitted by another thief.
Title — ‘question of trust’ — he trusted the wrong person.
‘Set a thief to catch a thief’ vs ‘honour among thieves’ — the story shows there is no honour among thieves.
👥 Character Sketches
Horace Danby — 50, respectable-looking, skilled lock-maker; careful planner; book lover; but dishonest and easily charmed; not a typical thief — steals only once a year, for books.
The lady in red — young, pretty, clever, smooth-talking, confident; a cunning thief who uses Horace.
📚 Word Meanings (शब्दार्थ)
Word
Meaning
हिंदी अर्थ
meticulous
very careful about details
सूक्ष्मता से काम करने वाला
hay fever
allergy to pollen
परागकण से एलर्जी
combination
secret number code of a lock
कोड / संयोजन
charming
attractive, pleasing
आकर्षक
culprit
person who committed a crime
अपराधी
bachelor
unmarried man
अविवाहित पुरुष
✅ NCERT Questions & Answers (English + हिंदी)
📌 Read and Find Out
Q1.What does Horace Danby like to collect?
He likes to collect rare and expensive books.
हॉरेस डैनबी को क्या इकट्ठा करना पसंद है?
उसे दुर्लभ और महँगी किताबें इकट्ठा करना पसंद है।
Q2.★ IMPWhy does he steal every year?
He steals one safe every year to get enough money to buy rare and expensive books for the next twelve months.
वह हर साल चोरी क्यों करता है?
वह हर साल एक तिजोरी चुराता है ताकि अगले बारह महीनों के लिए दुर्लभ, महँगी किताबें खरीदने लायक पैसे मिल जाएँ।
Q3.Who is speaking to Horace Danby?
A young, pretty lady dressed in red, who pretends to be the lady of the house.
हॉरेस डैनबी से कौन बात कर रहा है?
लाल कपड़ों में एक युवा सुंदर महिला, जो घर की मालकिन होने का नाटक करती है।
Q4.★ IMPWho is the real culprit in the story?
The lady in red is the real culprit. She tricked Horace into opening the safe and stole the jewels, while Horace was punished.
कहानी में असली अपराधी कौन है?
लाल कपड़ों वाली महिला असली अपराधी है। उसने हॉरेस से तिजोरी खुलवाकर गहने चुराए, जबकि सज़ा हॉरेस को मिली।
📌 Think about it
Q5.★ IMPDid you suspect that the lady was not the owner of the house? When did you begin to suspect her?
Yes. I began to suspect when she did not call the police and instead asked a thief to open the safe, saying she had forgotten the combination. A real owner would have called the police.
क्या आपको शक हुआ कि महिला घर की मालकिन नहीं है? कब?
हाँ। जब उसने पुलिस नहीं बुलाई और एक चोर से तिजोरी खुलवाई, यह कहते हुए कि वह कोड भूल गई है — तब शक हुआ। असली मालकिन पुलिस बुलाती।
Q6.★ IMPWhat are the subtle ways in which the lady manipulates Horace into opening the safe? Why didn’t Horace suspect that something was wrong?
She was confident and charming, knew about the house, smoked calmly, spoke of her husband being away and a party, threatened to call the police and then appeared generous by not doing so. Horace was frightened of prison and flattered by her charm, so he did not suspect her.
महिला ने हॉरेस को तिजोरी खोलने के लिए कैसे चालाकी से मनाया? हॉरेस को शक क्यों नहीं हुआ?
वह आत्मविश्वासी और आकर्षक थी, घर के बारे में जानती थी, आराम से सिगरेट पी रही थी, पति के बाहर होने की बात कही, पुलिस की धमकी दी और फिर उदार बनकर नहीं बुलाई। हॉरेस जेल से डरा हुआ था और उसके आकर्षण में आ गया, इसलिए शक नहीं किया।
Q7.Horace Danby was good and respectable — but not completely honest. Why do you think this description is apt for Horace? Why can’t he be categorised as a typical thief?
He looked respectable and worked as a lock-maker, but he stole once a year, so he was not completely honest. He was not a typical thief because he stole only once a year, only for books (not luxury), planned carefully, and was kind (e.g., to the dog).
हॉरेस अच्छा और सम्मानित था पर पूरी तरह ईमानदार नहीं — यह वर्णन उपयुक्त क्यों है? वह सामान्य चोर क्यों नहीं है?
वह सम्मानित दिखता था और ताले बनाता था, पर साल में एक बार चोरी करता था, इसलिए पूरी तरह ईमानदार नहीं था। वह सामान्य चोर नहीं था क्योंकि वह केवल साल में एक बार, केवल किताबों के लिए चोरी करता था और सावधानी से योजना बनाता था।
Q8.★ IMPHorace Danby was a meticulous planner but still he faltered. Where did he go wrong and why?
He went wrong when he trusted the lady and took off his gloves, leaving fingerprints on the safe. He was nervous, wanted to escape prison, and was charmed by her, so he forgot his own caution.
हॉरेस बहुत सावधानी से योजना बनाता था, फिर भी चूक गया। कहाँ और क्यों?
उसने महिला पर भरोसा किया और दस्ताने उतार दिए, जिससे तिजोरी पर उँगलियों के निशान रह गए। वह घबराया हुआ था, जेल से बचना चाहता था और महिला के आकर्षण में आ गया, इसलिए अपनी सावधानी भूल गया।
🔥 Extra Important Questions for Board Exam
⚡ Board Favourite यह प्रश्न पिछले वर्षों में बार-बार पूछे गए प्रकार के हैं।
Q9.★ IMPDo you think Horace was unfairly punished?
Horace was a thief and had entered the house to steal, so he deserved punishment. Yet it is ironic that he was punished for a theft he did not complete, while the real thief escaped.
क्या हॉरेस को अनुचित सज़ा मिली?
हॉरेस चोरी करने ही घर में घुसा था, इसलिए सज़ा का हक़दार था। पर विडंबना यह है कि उसे वह चोरी के लिए सज़ा मिली जो उसने पूरी नहीं की, जबकि असली चोर बच गई।
🎯 Exam Tips & Quick Revision
Facts: 50 years, £15,000, two weeks, Sherry, hay fever, lady in red.
Mistake: removed gloves.
End: assistant librarian.
🌟 Message / Value (सीख) Wrong means lead to wrong ends; never trust strangers blindly.